After her appearance on season three of the popular TV show
The Voice, Melanie Martinez was quickly on her way to becoming a star. She was eliminated in the fifth week; however she immediately went to work on solo work, and in 2015, her first full album came out, entitled
Cry Baby.
My favorite thing about this album and the songs featured on it is that, like the title, they all have a very childlike title and sound to it; however, the lyrics and deeper meanings are incredibly dark and real. In this post, I'll be digging into some of those lyrics. (another interesting thing is that the album is set up like a storybook; in fact, there's a storybook about it
here.)
The most popular song to come off of that album was probably
Dollhouse. The message in it is fairly clear, and there's a lot of lines that you can examine. For example,
You don't hear me when I say,
"Mom, please wake up.
Dad's with a slut, and your son is smoking cannabis."
The main character (a character called "Cry Baby" by Martinez) has tried many times to expose the truth; but no one will listen. Then in the chorus,
Places, places, get in your places
Throw on your dress and put on your doll faces.
Everyone thinks that we're perfect
Please don't let them look through the curtains.
Picture, picture, smile for the picture
Pose with your brother, won't you be a good sister?
Everyone thinks that we're perfect
Please don't let them look through the curtains.
So these lines are saying basically this family always pretends to be something their not in order to hide their flaws. If anyone looked a little bit closer, they'd be able to see all the cracks and flaws; they'd be able to see that this family is not so perfect after all. This is reinforced with the lines about the mother:
Hey girl, look at my mom, she's got it going on
Ha, you're blinded by her jewelry.
When you turn your back she pulls out a flask
And forgets his infidelity.
These lines help add to the idea that the family and all the individual members are putting on a façade, a mask that is not really them. But when "you" look away, they become who they really are; and when "you" look back, they are back to being the perfect, picturesque family that you know and love. These ideas could easily apply to individual people as well, who hide their feelings. I know that I for one can relate; when people are looking, I'm happy and cheerful and have a handle on my life. But as soon as the door is shut, as soon as no eyes are on me, I am not so happy or cheerful; I don't know what I'm doing at all. Martinez, in this song, is trying to get across that you can't do that forever; someone knows what happens behind closed doors. Someone knows the feelings you are hiding. And whatever you're hiding is going to come to light sooner or later, so why not save the pain and just reveal it yourself?
Another song that has a very dark message like this one also has to do with the mother described in Dollhouse; in fact, the message itself is similar as well. This song is
Sippy Cup. The song opens up with the chorus (of which is what is mainly repeated, and carries a majority of the message):
Blood still stains when the sheets are washed
Sex don't sleep when the lights are off
Kids are still depressed when you dress them up
And syrup is still syrup in a sippy cup
He's still dead when you're done with the bottle
Of course it's a corpse that you keep in the cradle
Kids are still depressed when you dress them up
Syrup is still syrup in a sippy cup
So what this stanza is saying is basically that things will continue to happen no matter how hard you try to cover them up or get rid of them. Trying to dress a crappy product up with fancy words, for example, won't change how crappy the product is. The line that I struggle to understand is the "of course it's a corpse that you keep in the cradle." No matter how hard I've tried, I haven't been able to tie that line in with the rest of the song, aside from the fact that it keeps to the dark theme. Perhaps it means that even with a dead baby, keeping it in the cradle won't make it any less dead? Anywho. The only other stanza that I feel carries important lines is:
Pill diet, pill diet, if they give you a new pill then you will buy it
If they say to kill yourself, then you will try it
All the makeup in the world, won't make you less insecure
You got weights in your pockets, when you go to the doctor's
Your favorite candy's cotton, that's why all your teeth are rotten
Silly girl with silly boys
I found this stanza interesting, given what we've been talking about regarding ads and persuasion. The song seems to imply that the mother (who I assume is still the subject) needs very little persuasion, and instead almost depends on the media to tell her what to do; I feel like many people have this same issue, especially nowadays. The lines add even more to the trying to cover up the truth with sweet lies. The overall message that I got from this song was basically that: no matter how hard you want to look good, the truth will always come out.
The final song that I'll be analyzing has a slightly more uplifting message, in a way; you have to read the lyrics as Martinez speaking as if she believes the words she's saying, when the message is really the opposite. This song is
Mrs. Potato Head. The very first lines are:
If you weren't born with it
You can buy a couple ornaments
Just be sure to read the warning, kids
'Cause pretty soon you'll be bored of it, ha-ha
This stanza talks about how easy it is to get the appearance that you want, nowadays; all you have to do is buy a surgery and you can instantly be whatever you want to be. The warning, though, is that consumers will quickly become bored with what they've done and want to change it again, and again, and again; this will have negative effects. So, Martinez warns them to "read the warning." Then, the lines leading into the chorus are:
Don't be dramatic, it's only some plastic
No one will love you if you're unattractive
These are the lines that I was talking about she says them almost ironically, in a way. She says them because she knows that this is what the people she is trying to get this message across to are thinking. As if it's no big deal that they are changing what they were born as; their justification is that no one will love them if they're not beautiful. Then, immediately following, is the chorus:
Oh Mrs. Potato Head tell me, is it true that pain is beauty?
Does a new face come with a warranty?
Will a pretty face make it better?
Oh Mr. Potato Head, tell me
How did you afford her surgery?
Do you swear you'll stay forever?
Even if her face don't stay together
I think this stanza is trying to emphasize the downsides to plastic surgery. They're incredibly expensive, as mentioned in the line addressing Mr. Potato Head, and can be quite painful. It takes the common phrase that people hear - "pain is beauty" - and asks if that is really true, if she really believes that. Then she follows up asking if a new face will be the solution she was looking for. I also believe the line asking if a new face comes with a warranty is alluding the fact that Mrs. Potato Head will not be happy with her new face, because it will turn out not to be the solution she was looking for, and she's going to want to change it again. It almost feels as if Martinez is taking pity on Mrs. Potato Head, and encourages Mr. Potato Head to stay with her, even if she is not always "beautiful" like she is trying to be. The next verse follows with:
If you want a little more confidence
Potatoes turn to french fries, yeah it's common sense
All you need's a couple more condiments
And a hundred thousand dollars for some compliments
It's such a waste
When little girls grow into their mother's face
But little girls are learning how to cut and paste
And pucker up their lips until they suffocate
So the opening to this stanza reinforces how easy it is nowadays to become more "beautiful" with just a little surgery. It also emphasizes how expensive and wasteful the money to pay for it is, by saying that its all that money for just a few compliments. I believe that also adds to how she is saying that little will really change. The second half of the verse is slightly more confusing to me, because she switches back to speaking against what she believes; she doesn't really think it's a waste, I don't think, that little girls grow to look like their mothers. She is saying how "good" it is that the girls are learning how to improve themselves. What really clues in the fact that she does not mean what she is saying is how she says "pucker up their lips until they suffocate." In all, this song is trying to say (in a very roundabout and darkly-described way) that we are all beautiful as we are, and to try and change ourselves is a waste of money for something that will only come apart with time anyway.
Melanie Martinez's songs are incredibly catchy, incredibly dark, and incredibly deep. I highly recommend her music to pretty much anyone, and I hope that it is as easy to decipher the meaning to the lyrics as it is to me.
More to report.
-M